Cashflow
Cash positive but tax negative: how that happens
By FreeHolder · · 7 min read
A rental property can leave you with more money in your account at the end of the year and still show a loss on your tax return. The two numbers measure different things. Cashflow counts what actually moves in and out of your bank account, including the principal you repay on your loan. Your rental income or loss for tax counts what the tax rules treat as income and deductions, which generally includes depreciation, a deduction you don't pay for in cash that year, and leaves out loan principal.
Once you see the two side by side, the gap stops being confusing and becomes something you can track.
The tax rules quoted here are from the ATO's Rental properties 2026 guide, which covers the 2025–26 financial year.
What does "cash positive" mean?
Your property is cash positive when the rent coming in is more than everything going out: running costs (agent fees, strata levies, rates, insurance, repairs) plus your full loan repayments.
That's the number most investors feel. It decides whether you're topping up the property from your salary each month or not.
What does "tax negative" mean?
The ATO works out net rental income or loss as gross rent minus total deductible expenses (Rental properties 2026 worksheet, for 2025–26). When deductions are bigger than the rent, the result is a rental loss.
The ATO calls this negative gearing. In its words, when rental income is less than the deductible expenses, including interest, "you have an amount which may reduce your other assessable income" (Rental properties 2026: other tax considerations). Whether, and how much, that affects your tax depends on your circumstances.
Why are the two numbers different?
Two items sit on opposite sides of the line.
Loan principal: in your cashflow, not in your deductions. For a loan used to buy a rental property, the deduction is for "the interest charged on the loan" (ATO, interest expenses). On a principal and interest loan, part of every repayment reduces the loan itself. That part leaves your account, so it's in your cashflow, but it isn't interest, so it isn't in the deduction.
Depreciation: in your deductions, not in your cashflow. Two kinds of deduction cover the wear on a rental property over time:
- Capital works deductions for construction costs, such as the building and structural improvements. For a residential rental building where construction started after 15 September 1987, the rate is generally 2.5% a year, which spreads the deduction over 40 years from completion (ATO, work out your capital works deductions; Rental properties 2026: rental expenses).
- Deductions for decline in value of depreciating assets such as ovens, hot water systems and blinds (same guide). There's a limit for certain second-hand depreciating assets in residential rental properties, where the asset was contracted for, or otherwise acquired, after 7:30 pm on 9 May 2017, so not every asset in an established property qualifies (details).
You don't make a payment for either of these in the year you claim them. The money was spent when the building was constructed or the asset was bought; the deduction spreads that cost over the years.
So principal makes your cashflow look worse than your tax position, and depreciation makes your tax position look worse than your cashflow. When depreciation is larger than the principal you repay, you can be cash positive and tax negative at the same time.
A worked example
Example. Fictional portfolio: 14/22 Banksia Row, Braddon ACT and 7 Kurrajong Lane, Marrickville NSW. Financial year 2025–26. Principal and interest loans at around 6% a year, in their first year; the interest and principal figures are as they'd appear on the lender's annual statement. Depreciation figures as they'd come from each property's depreciation schedule. All figures are illustrative.
| Amount | |
|---|---|
| Rent received | $65,000 |
| Running costs (agent fees, strata, rates, insurance, repairs) | −$13,022 |
| Loan repayments: interest | −$41,200 |
| Loan repayments: principal | −$8,258 |
| Cashflow for the year | +$2,520 |
That's about $210 a month left over, so this portfolio is cash positive.
Now the tax view, using the ATO's approach of gross rent minus deductible expenses:
| Amount | |
|---|---|
| Rent received | $65,000 |
| Running costs | −$13,022 |
| Loan interest | −$41,200 |
| Depreciation (capital works and decline in value) | −$18,854 |
| Estimated net rental loss | −$8,076 |
The same portfolio shows an estimated rental loss of $8,076.
Where the $10,596 gap comes from:
| Amount | |
|---|---|
| Cashflow | +$2,520 |
| Add back principal (in cashflow, not a deduction) | +$8,258 |
| Take off depreciation (a deduction, not a cash payment) | −$18,854 |
| Estimated net rental loss | −$8,076 |
Check: $2,520 + $8,258 − $18,854 = −$8,076.
What happens to a rental loss?
The ATO explains that you may be able to claim rental expenses "against your rental and other income (such as salary, wages or business income)", and that "Where the other income isn't sufficient to absorb the loss, you can carry it forward to the next income year" (Rental properties 2026: other tax considerations). On PAYG withholding, the same page says: "If by negatively gearing a rental property, the rental expenses you claim in your tax return would result in a tax refund, you may reduce your rate of withholding to better match your tax liability at the end of the income year."
What a loss means for your own tax depends on your income and circumstances. We recommend a registered tax agent reviews your figures before you lodge.
From 1 July 2027, the rules change for established residential properties bought after "7:30pm AEST 12 May 2026": losses on those properties can only be used against income from residential properties, including capital gains, and any excess is carried forward. New builds, and properties held before that time, aren't affected (Budget 2026–27 tax explainer). We'll update this article before the new rules start.
Can it go the other way?
Yes. A property can be tax positive and cash negative: for example, an older property with little depreciation left, on a loan where a large share of each repayment is principal. You'd show net rental income for tax while still topping up the property each month.
The point isn't which combination is better. It's that one number on its own doesn't tell you where you stand.
Why track both?
- Cashflow tells you whether the property is paying its own way this month.
- The tax view gives you an estimate of where you'll stand at tax time, and shows what you, or your tax agent, will be working with.
- Both change over time. Each year more of a principal and interest repayment goes to principal. Decline in value deductions generally fall each year where the diminishing value method is used, while capital works deductions at 2.5% stay level until the 40 years run out. A property that's cash positive and tax negative today may not stay that way.
Keeping track of this
A spreadsheet can show either view, but keeping both up to date every month is where it usually falls over. FreeHolder shows cashflow on every plan, with rent, management fees, strata levies and loan repayments entered automatically each month from your details. On the Plus plan, it adds your depreciation figures and shows an estimate of each property's net rental position for the financial year, alongside the cash, with a year-end report you can share with your tax agent.
Sources
- ATO, Rental properties 2026: worksheet, work out your net rental income or loss, last updated 30 May 2026
- ATO, Rental properties 2026: other tax considerations, last updated 30 May 2026
- ATO, Rental properties 2026: rental expenses, last updated 30 May 2026
- ATO, Work out your capital works deductions
- ATO, Interest expenses, last updated 21 May 2026
- © Australian Taxation Office for the Commonwealth of Australia
Last reviewed: 2 November 2026
General information only, not tax or financial advice. Speak to your registered tax agent about your situation.